Legacy Ridge Ranch FoundationA 501(c)(3) nonprofit organizationEIN 41-5201120
Resource · Ranch knowledge

Reading the Horse Grimace Scale: Six Pain Signs

The Horse Grimace Scale scores six changes in a horse's face — ears, eyes, chewing muscles, mouth, and nostrils — each from 0 to 2, giving owners a shared language for pain they can see but struggle to describe. It supports observation; it never replaces a veterinarian.

Where the Scale Comes From

Grimace scales began in laboratory-animal welfare and reached horses in 2014, when a team led by Emanuela Dalla Costa filmed horses before and after routine castration and identified the facial changes that tracked pain, publishing the Horse Grimace Scale in the journal PLOS ONE. Trained observers using the scale agreed closely with each other, and scores fell when pain relief was given — the two tests a pain tool must pass. The scale has since been studied in other kinds of pain, including laminitis and dental disease, and it underlies much of the automated, camera-based pain-recognition research now under way.

The Six Signs, One by One

Each sign is scored 0 for not present, 1 for moderately present, and 2 for obviously present, for a total out of twelve. One: ears held stiffly backwards, fixed rather than flicking with attention. Two: orbital tightening — the eye narrowed, the eyelid partly closed, the eye looking smaller. Three: tension above the eye, the muscles standing out so the area looks angular and strained. Four: prominent, strained chewing muscles, the cheek tight and defined instead of soft. Five: a strained mouth with a pronounced chin, lips pressed, the chin looking knotted. Six: strained nostrils with a flattening of the face's profile. No single sign is proof; the pattern across the face is the signal.

How to Score Your Own Horse Honestly

The scale reads the face at rest, and horses hide pain in company — prey animals do — so observe from a distance, at a quiet time, when the horse does not know it is being watched: not before feeding, not just after work, not while it is attending to you. Score all six units and write the result down with the date. The value is in comparison — today's face against the same horse's ordinary face, and against yesterday's score — not in any single number. Photographing the resting face in the same light, once you know your horse's normal, gives you a reference that memory alone will not keep honestly.

What the Scale Cannot Do, and When to Call

The grimace scale does not diagnose, does not say where pain lives, and does not measure every kind of suffering — a horse can score low and still be seriously ill. Use it as an early-warning language: two or more signs appearing together, a score that persists or climbs through the day, or any changed face alongside the ordinary alarms — off feed, lying down more, moving stiffly, a changed temperament — is a reason to call your veterinarian and be able to say exactly what you saw and when it changed. That sentence, precise and dated, is what the scale was built to give you.

Keep reading

← Back to all resources

From the ranch

A rider turns a barrel on a bay horse in an outdoor arena
Outdoor arena run.
The ranch road lit at night
The ranch after dark.